Over the last decade, and especially
in the last 5 years or so, the NFL Draft has
undergone a small phenomenon in which some teams
are taking a chance and occasionally drafting an
"athlete" rather than a true position player.
Not sure what I mean? Well, we have a number of
candidates in this year's draft that will be a
part of this phenomenon as well; players who
played a certain position in college, but are
being asked to change that position in order to
make it in the NFL.
In the history of the NFL Draft,
teams have drafted players to play the position
they played in college. Thus, quarterbacks were
drafted to play quarterback, linebackers to play
linebacker, so on and so forth. Players that
did not excel at a position, or whose skills did
not translate to the NFL, went undrafted or made
futile attempts to play their college position
in the NFL. A new era donned upon us however
with the Pittsburg Steelers drafting of Kordell
Stewart, the quarterback from Colorado, in the
2nd round of the 1995 draft. Stewart was an
above average college quarterback with elite
athleticism and an innate ability for making the
big play. However, Stewart's arm strength and
accuracy were questioned, as was his ability to
be a field general. Thusly, the Steelers
drafted him as an athlete, where during his
career, he played QB, WR, RB, and even punted.
He instantly became a sensation both on the
field and off. The moniker of "Slash" was
attached to him as he played QB/WR/RB. I am
sure we all remember the play he made in the
playoffs early in his career where he rolled
right, reversed field to the opposite sideline
and delivered a strike in the end zone. He
became the most versatile weapon in the NFL.
This is not a new concept in the college game,
as players switch positions all the time, and
some of the top prep players are faced with the
difficult decision of deciding (or their coaches
deciding) which side of the ball they will be
relegated to in college. Some players of note
that have been moved around significantly during
their time in college are Hines Ward, who played
everywhere, Champ Bailey, Charles Woodson,
Antwaan Randle-El who played WR one season, Matt
Jones who also started a season at WR, Jevon
Kearse, Michael Robinson, Leonard Davis, Marcus
Outzen, etc. There are more than one can name
in a single article. College coaches have more
flexibility and want to maximize the ability and
impact each player on his team can make, thus
the reasoning behind players moving positions.
The single most important part of this trend in
the college game is that coaches want their
"best 11" on the field at a given time, and as
such, will move players to accomplish this goal.
As for the NFL, most of the time, getting
the "best 11" on the field did not involve this
phenomenon as coaches were dealing with the best
of the best at every position, so the necessity
was not there. Recently however, some players'
athletic abilities have been too good to ignore,
and while they may not play a position a team is
not in need of, the raw athletic ability of
these young men stirs a front office to draft
someone on the potential one possesses. Thus,
the trend began over a decade ago with Kordell
Stewart and is alive and well today. Some
prominent NFL players who are part of this new
wave of NFL player are:
* Hines Ward: Ward showcased his versatility
at Georgia, playing a variety of positions from
QB to safety, and has translated his tremendous
athletic ability into a NFL game that ranks him
as one of the top receivers in the league. All
of this too while playing without an ACL in one
knee.
* Antwaan Randle-El: It seems the Steelers
are the leaders of this trend, as Randle-El
played QB, WR, and PR in the NFL, with most of
his time spent as an option QB. His versatility
has added a dimension to the Steelers' offense,
as he is always a threat to run a reverse, take
a snap at QB, run an option, or throw the ball
off a reverse.
* Matt Jones: a freak athlete at 6'6", 247
lbs, 4.4/40, Jones made the transition from QB
to WR seem virtually effortless as shown by his
decent rookie production and highlight reel
catches that are played over and over again.
* Jevon Kearse: Kearse is the epitome of a
team drafting someone based on raw athletic
ability. Kearse started his career at Florida
as a hard hitting safety. The coaching staff
continued to add muscle to his lean frame,
eventually moving him to linebacker. The Titans
saw a rare physical specimen, drafted Kearse,
and moved him to defensive end where he had 14.5
sacks as a rookie.
* David Pollack: Pollack was highly
productive at Georgia, but a bit undersized to
play defensive end in the NFL. As such, the
Bengals took a chance on his good athletic
ability and high motor, drafted him, and moved
him to linebacker where he started to make an
impact at the end of the season.
* Ronald Curry: Curry was Mr. Football and
Mr. Basketball a high school senior and because
of this, was highly recruited in both sports.
Curry chose North Carolina where he had an
immediate impact in both sports. A torn
Achilles tendon in college hampered his
development as a quarterback and point guard,
but his athletic ability was too hard for the
Raiders to ignore. He was drafted originally to
return kicks, but settled in as a wide
receiver. Curry was starting to break out both
in 2004 and in 2005 before two more torn
Achilles tendons put his seasons to an end and
possible career in jeopardy.
* Patrick Crayton: Crayton went undrafted,
but has made a good transition from quarterback
to wide receiver.
* Brian Mitchell: though now retired,
Mitchell was an excellent option quarterback in
college, but the NFL game caused the need for
him to make a switch, which he did. As a
running back, Mitchell made an average impact,
however his kick and punt return skills made
Mitchell an invaluable player throughout his
career.
* Scott Frost: Frost ran the Nebraska option
attack like a pro, however the absence of the
option in the NFL created the need for Frost to
make himself valuable to the NFL. To do so,
Frost made the move to safety where he was
drafted by the Jets and proved to be a solid
backup and special team's player.
* Eric Crouch: again, another Huskers QB
forced to make a position switch, which he was
almost defiant to. Was drafted in the third
round by the Rams, who hoped to move Crouch to
WR, but a nagging hamstring injury and his
inability to learn the nuances of the position
led to his abrupt retirement before his rookie
season. Crouch attempted to make a comeback
with the Packers as a safety, but was promptly
cut during training camp.
* Michael Boulware: a linebacker at Florida
State, Seattle did not think Boulware had the
size to stay injury free at linebacker and since
he had elite speed and coverage ability for a
linebacker, the Seahawks moved him to safety
where he has thrived in his two seasons. He is
a major impact player in the ball-hawking
Seattle secondary.
* Thomas Davis: a hard-hitting safety at
Georgia, Davis started the season as the starter
at safety in Carolina; however he often looked
lost and eventually lost his starting spot to
Marlon McCree. Later in the season, he was used
as a spy LB when the Panthers played the
Falcons, as he has the speed necessary to keep
up with Michael Vick. Since he has marginal
coverage skills, Davis will probably remain a
fulltime LB for the rest of his career.
* Cato June: another college safety who was
deemed too slow to play it in the NFL, June was
moved to LB by Indy, and as this season showed
us all, June is a playmaker. If he can fight
off the injury bug, June will continue to make
an impact in the NFL.
As you can see, many teams have taken a chance
on guys that would be average prospects at their
"natural" positions and drafted them based on
athletic potential alone. Some teams have
reaped the benefits of this (Steelers) while
others have been burned, namely the Rams
drafting Eric Crouch. To be successful at this
switch, a player need be flexible, hardworking,
confident in his athletic ability, and have a
desire to learn. Crouch was stubborn about the
position change and not willing to put in the
work necessary to succeed at a new position.
Ward on the other hand, has turned himself into
one of the best WRs in the NFL, be it catching,
running routes, or blocking.
There are a number of players in the
2006 draft who face the possibility of getting
drafted because of their status as elite
athletes. Here is a short highlight of some of
those.
* Michael Robinson, QB Penn State: Robinson
has played RB, WR, QB, and even some defense
during his time in Happy Valley. Unfortunately
for him, he lacks the pure arm strength and
accuracy necessary to be productive as an NFL
quarterback. Thus, Robinson will have to put on
one of his many hats and will get drafted by a
team that can afford to give Robinson two
seasons to become acclimated to a new position.
He will be an immediate threat as a kick
returner however. At 6'1" 210lbs, Robinson has
great size and above average speed.
* Barrick Nealy, QB Texas State: Nealy had an
amazing season, leading Texas State to the Div.
1-AA semifinals. However he lacks the accuracy
and big-time game experience necessary to enjoy
success as an NFL quarterback. This was shown
in the Hula Bowl, where Nealy looked lost and
could not hit a WR. However at 6'5" 225lbs and
a 40 in the 4.5 range, Nealy is intriguing as he
has similar measurables to Matt Jones. Nealy
will be best served as a WR in the NFL.
* Greg Blue: Just like former fellow teammate
Thomas Davis, Blue might make the move to LB
because of his limited coverage abilities. No
matter what team gets him, Blue is one of the
hardest hitters in the nation who has a knack
for making the big play.
* Garrett Mills: Tulsa's great TE is very
small at 6'3" 230lbs, so will probably make the
move to more of a H-back or FB role, much like
Chris Cooley did. Mills' ability to catch the
ball will make him an invaluable contributor on
a team that runs a version of the west-coast
offense and will be valuable on special teams as
well, as he has a big "motor" as well.
* Devin Hester: at around 6'0" 180lbs and
running a sub 4.4, Hester will be in hot demand
in the second round. Hester has no true
position, though he was slated to be the next
great 'Cane DB. Most of his time and also
abilities were spent as a RB, WR, PR, KR. Some
team will draft him and find creative ways to
utilize his rare athletic ability. He probably
would have been best served by remaining in
school another season however.
This trend looks like it will remain around in
the near future, as with the evolution of
offensive and defensive schemes, teams are
looking to put the best players on the field in
the NFL now, and if that means drafting a player
in hopes of them having success at another
position, so be it. Teams are more willing now
than ever to gamble, as many teams are not
hinging their franchises on the draft anymore.
Here is wishing success to all of those that are
facing this decision. In the opinion of most
NFL scouts, players should do whatever it takes
to make an impact, and if that means utilizing
one's athletic ability at a different position,
so be it. Only three more months...