Now that the NFL season is over, we will
now be inundated with reports from the NFL
Combine in Indianapolis as well as the rumors
that circulate over the workouts that draft
prospects have at their pro days at their
respective schools. As such, we will now be
faced with the typical 5-10 players who will
soar up draft boards based on these workouts
alone, no matter how marginal their play was as
in college. In the history of the NFL, their
have been some fairly significant workout
warriors who have lifted and run themselves into
higher draft positions than they would have had
otherwise. Here is a list of the top-5 workout
warriors from the last 20 years as well as a few
players that could be part of this phenomenon
this season.
1. Tony Mandarich: next to Ryan Leaf, the
biggest bust in NFL draft history and also the
greatest workout warrior ever. Mandarich
received so much hype, that he was named to the
All-Madden Team while still in college at
Michigan State. Coming in at 6'6" and 315 lbs,
Mandarich had no fat on him, but rather had the
scuplted physique of a bodybuilder while playing
LT. At the NFL Combine in 1989, Mandarich ran a
4.65 40, long jumped 10 feet 3 inches, had a 30
inch vertical jump, and had 39 reps in the bench
at 225 lbs. All of this as well as his above
average play in college sent him to the Green
Bay Packers where he fizzled out after 4 seasons
then did the same after 3 seasons in Indy. Oh
yeah, he later admitted to rampant steroid use.
2. Mike Mamula: The Boston College DE was viewed
as a decent college player who might be a
3rd-5th round pick, but his amazing workouts
translated into him being propelled into the
first round, going to the Eagles with the 7th
pick in the draft in 1995. What followed was a
disappointing 6 year career, in which he never
registered more than 5 sacks in a season. He
retired in 2000.
3. Kyle Boller: Boller was one of Jeff Tedford's
pet projects at Cal who enjoyed some success as
a Bear, but questions abounded about his lack of
accuracy, as he never completed more than 59% of
his passes in a season in college, and only had
a 51% completion percentage for his college
career. Nevertheless, scouts drooled over his
workouts in which he ran a 4.6 40, showed
amazing fluidity in his movements, and then
threw a football through the uprights from the
50 yard line while on his knees. That last
performance especially propelled Boller from a
probable second round pick to a mid first
rounder to the Ravens. So far, we have gotten
mixed results from Boller's play, though he did
seem to pull it together at the end of the 2005
season.
4. Boss Bailey: the Georgia LB turned in an
amazing performance during his NFL Combine and
Pro Day. At 6'4" 230lbs, Bailey ripped off a
4.45 40 and had a 46'-48' vertical jump
depending on your source. Scouts also saw the
genetics (brother Champ) and fell in love with
the marginal prospect, propelling him to the
Lions in the early second round. His NFL career has
been marred by injuries, though there have been
some flashes of true talent. The jury is still
out.
5. Donte Stallworth and Ashley Lelie: the WRs
were both viewed as probable second round picks,
as Stallworth did not have the production and
health that scouts desired and Lelie was deemed
too skinny and played in an offense that made
his production exceed his actual skill. Then
they ran their 40s. Lelie ran a 4.35 at 6'3"
190 lbs. Immediately, scouts started following
his every move, and ESPN devoted an entire
player diary to him. Then Stallworth ran
anywhere between 4.19 and 4.27 and it made his
decision to leave early and the NCAA's decision
to not allow him to be reinstated after leaving
school for the draft and changing his mind a
smart one. Both performances propelled each
into the first round and in fact left them
jockeying for position as the first WR off the
board. Both players have had moderate success
in the NFL, but not the success and production
that was expected of each after the 2002 draft.
Both have been incredibly inconsistent and
injury prone.
As for future workout warriors, here is a list
of 3 which could have a "underwear performance"
that could translate into millions of dollars.
1. Antonio Cromartie: like Willis McGahee before
him, Cromartie is gambling on entering the draft
early after a devastating knee injury.
Cromartie tore his ACL in the summer of 2005 and
missed the entire season, yet still opted to
leave Florida State early for the 2006 draft.
Now that he is nearly healed and participated in
some workouts with the team, Cromartie should
impress with his workouts, since he has the size
and speed scouts dream of in CBs. However, one
needs to remember he only has one season of
starting experience under his belt, is coming
off an injury that can take up to a year to
heal, and has lived off the hype of the end of
the 2004 season in which Cromartie played well.
2. Devin Hester: Here is betting that Hester
rips off the best 40 time of any player in this
year's draft. The 6'0" speedster from Miami has
experience at WR, CB, RB, and KR and PR.
However, Hester has never been able to settle
into a true position and has not been able to
unseat any other player on Miami's roster for a
starting spot. While it is true that he is an
electric player and a dynamic kick and punt returner, Hester is still without a true
position. Any team drafting him will have to
endure 2-3 seasons of grooming, but his
potential alone will make him a viable first day
pick. His workouts will have scouts buzzing
similar to that of Matt Jones last year.
3. Marcus Vick: Like Adrian McPherson in the
2005 draft, Vick has a chance to impress scouts
with his athletic ability in hopes that it will
overshadow his off the field and now on the
field transgressions. Scouts expecting to see
shades of Michael will be impressed by Marcus'
touch on his throws, better drop back skills,
above average arm strength, good speed, and well
developed knowledge of the game. However, his
off the field troubles exceed even those of
McPherson and spell trouble for any team
thinking about drafting him. He will improve
his stock significantly with his workouts, going
from a 4th-5th round pick to a late 2nd or 3rd
rounder.
This workout warrior phenomenon will be one that
will live forever, because no matter the
production or lack thereof, off the field
history, injury history, or lack of passion for
the game, scouts will still put too much stock
in the measurables that come from the combine
and pro-days. It now becomes interesting to see
who teams will gamble on based on those numbers
alone.