Vogel’s 2023 NFL Draft Big Board 1.0 (Pre-Combine)

The NFL Draft is one of the most anticipated events of the year, receiving unlimited media coverage and setting high expectations for fanbases as they eagerly watch in anticipation to see who will be the future stars of their franchises.

As an NFL Draft analyst, it’s my job to project for you who those stars will be.

This top 100 board is a rough projection of where I expect these players to grade out. Most of the grades on these players aren’t done yet – you can keep up with all of my scouting reports and grades at this link.

This really isn’t a list of where I think guys will go – it’s more of how I project them forward with their careers.

That being said, let’s get into it!

The Top 25

ATLANTA, GA – DECEMBER 31: Georgia Bulldogs defensive lineman Jalen Carter (88) during the college football Playoff Semifinal game at the Chick-fil-a Peach Bowl between the Georgia Bulldogs and the Ohio State Buckeyes on December 31, 2022 at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Michael Wade/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

One thing that you will notice missing from the top 25 players – quarterbacks. Most of the quarterbacks in this class have not graded out well to my system – which now favors mobile playmakers who can get out of the pocket and make good throws. The two here are Bryce Young and Hendon Hooker – my top two graded quarterbacks so far.

RankPOSPlayer NameSchool
1EDGEWill Anderson JrAlabama
2DTJalen CarterGeorgia
3QBBryce YoungAlabama
4EDGEMyles MurphyClemson
5EDGEIsaiah FoskeyNotre Dame
6DTBryan BreseeClemson
7EDGEKJ HenryClemson
8CBJoey Porter JrPenn State
9OGO’Cyrus TorrenceFlorida
10RBBijan RobinsonTexas
11LBHenry To’o To’oAlabama
12RBJahmyr GibbsAlabama
13SKelly RingoGeorgia
14WRZay FlowersBoston College
15OGPeter SkoronskiNorthwestern
16EDGEBJ OjulariLSU
17CBDevon WitherspoonIllinois
18OTJaelyn DuncanMaryland
19LBSirVocea DennisPittsburgh
20CBMekhi BlackmonUSC
21QBHendon HookerTennessee
22WRKayshon BoutteLSU
23EDGEDerrick HallAuburn
24RBSean TuckerSyracuse
25OTMatthew BergeronSyracuse

Another thing that stands out is the sheer number of defensive linemen that fill the top of the class. This is a particularly strong defensive line class at all positions. The rest of the position groups aren’t very top heavy – which bolsters the valuable defensive linemen toward the top.

Vogel’s Big Board: 26-50

INGLEWOOD, CA – DECEMBER 18: Oregon State Beavers tight end Luke Musgrave (88) runs a route during the Jimmy Kimmel LA Bowl college football game between the Utah State Aggies and the Oregon State Beavers on December 18, 2021, at SoFi Stadium in Inglewood, CA (Photo by Brandon Sloter/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

This class of tight ends looks like it could be very good, and it’s hard to rank them. I know the media favorite is typically Michael Mayer from Notre Dame – that’s a player who could be very good at his craft, which is mostly as a receiver and not as a blocker. I like Luke Musgrave a lot. His versatile skillset could propel him into the first round.

RankPOSPlayer NameSchool
26RBTank BigsbyAuburn
27CBGarrett WilliamsSyracuse
28TELuke MusgraveOregon State
29SChristopher SmithGeorgia
30CJohn Michael SchmitzMinnesota
31CBClark PhillipsUtah
32QBAnthony RichardsonFlorida
33SArquan BushCincinnati
34OTCody MauchNorth Dakota State
35LBDrew SandersArkansas
36SBrandon HillPittsburgh
37TEPayne DurhamPurdue
38LBVentrell MillerFlorida
39RBKenny McIntoshGeorgia
40WRJonathan MingoOle Miss
41TEMichael MayerNotre Dame
42EDGEWill McDonald Iowa State
43OTParris JohnsonOhio State
44WRQuentin JohnsonTCU
45QBCJ StroudOhio State
46LBJack CampbellIowa
47WRJordan AddisonUSC
48CBRejzohn WrightOregon State
49EDGETyree Wilson Texas Tech
50NTSiaki IkaBaylor

Vogel’s Big Board: 51-75

LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY – NOVEMBER 26: Will Levis #7 of the Kentucky Wildcats throws a pass against the Louisville Cardinals at Kroger Field on November 26, 2022 in Lexington, Kentucky. (Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images)

The disconnect between the old theories of football scouting and the modern analytical approach is perfectly polarized on Kentucky quarterback Will Levis. Every old school scout I’ve spoken with thinks he’s a third round talent. Every younger scout I’ve spoken with thinks he’s a top five pick.

I think that there’s merit to both claims – I tend to agree that his talent grades him in the third round, but he’s probably going to get drafted by a quarterback needy team top five.

RankPOSPlayer NameSchool
51RBZach EvansTCU
52CBTre’Vius Hodges-TomlinsonTCU
53NTKeeanu BentonWisconsin
54GSteve AvilaTCU
55SJordan BattleAlabama
56EDGEAli GayeLSU
57LBSeth BensonIowa
58WRJalin HyattTennessee
59EDGEZach HarrisonOhio State
60DTPJ MustipherPenn State
61QBWill LevisKentucky
62COlusegun OluwatimiMichigan
63OTJaxson KirklandWashington
64EDGEAndre Carter IIArmy
65WRCedric TillmanTennessee
66DLCalijah KanceyPittsburgh
67DTCameron YoungMississippi State
68EDGEHabakkuk BaldonadoPittsburgh
69TETucker KraftSouth Dakota State
70DTColby WootenAuburn
71RBTyjae SpearsTulane
72CBTyrique StevensonMiami (FL)
73DLKarl BrooksBowling Green
74LBDrake ThomasNorth Carolina State
75GEmil EkiyorAlabama

Vogel’s Big Board: 76-100

IOWA CITY, IA – SEPTEMBER 03: South Dakota State quarterback Mark Gronowski (11) tries to escape the grasp of Iowa left defensive tackle Lukas Van Ness (91) during a college football game between the South Dakota State Jackrabbits and the Iowa Hawkeyes, September 03, 2022, at Kinnick Stadium, Iowa City, IA. Photo by Keith Gillett/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images),

A guy starting to pick up a lot of media attention is Lukas Van Ness, the Iowa defensive end. He has solid length, athleticism, and could end up going a lot earlier than 76th.

RankPOSPlayer NameSchool
76EDGELukas Van NessIowa
77DTNesta Jade SilveraArizona State
78SBrian BranchAlabama
79OTRyan HayesMichigan
80 DT Byron YoungAlabama
81 CBEli RicksAlabama
82EDGERobert Beal JrGeorgia
83SSydney BrownIllinois
84OTBlake FreelandBYU
85CBDarius RushSouth Carolina
86LBJeremy BanksTennessee
87NTJaquelin RoyLSU
88EDGENolan SmithGeorgia
89LBDorian WilliamsTulane
90EDGEJose RamirezEastern Michigan
91CJuice ScruggsPenn State
92GJordan McFaddenClemson
93CBJulius BrentsKansas State
94LBCam JonesIndiana
95EDGENick HerbigWisconsin
96DLDante StillsWest Virginia
97SMalachi MooreAlabama
98CBKyu Blu-KellyStanford
99CBJarrick Bernard-ConverseLSU
100DTTyler DavisClemson

Other Names to Watch:

There were some other players who were close to making the cut that could really impress over the next couple of months, between the Combine and their pro days. Here are some of the guys to keep an eye on:

  • WR Jadon Haselwood, Arkansas
  • WR Andrei Iosavas, Princeton
  • WR Puka Nacoa, BYU
  • TE Josh Whyle, Cincinnati
  • OG McClendon Curtis, Chattanooga
  • EDGE Brenton Cox Jr, Florida
  • EDGE YaYa Diaby, Louisville
  • EDGE Ikenna Enchukwu, Rice
  • EDGE Thomas Incoom, Central Michigan
  • LB Ivan Pace Jr, Cincinnati
  • CB Emmanuel Forbes, Mississippi State

John Vogel

Learn More →